MLS Next Pro   M. W D L goals
  at home 3 0 1 1 2 : 3
  Away 6 0 0 5 7 : 16
  9 0 1 6 9 : 19
overall   M. W D L goals
  at home 3 0 1 1 2 : 3
  Away 6 0 0 5 7 : 16
  Neutral Place 0 0 0 0 0 : 0
  9 0 1 6 9 : 19
MLS Next Pro
2024 5. Round Columbus Crew 2 - Toronto FC 2 7:6 (0:0, 2:2) pso
2024 3. Round Toronto FC 2 - Columbus Crew 2 1:3 (1:0, 1:1) pso
2024 2. Round Columbus Crew 2 - Toronto FC 2 2:1 (2:1)
2023 6. Round Columbus Crew 2 - Toronto FC 2 4:0 (2:0)
2023 5. Round Toronto FC 2 - Columbus Crew 2 2:3 (2:1)
2022 Playoffs Semi-finals Columbus Crew 2 - Toronto FC 2 4:3 aet
2022 5. Round Toronto FC 2 - Columbus Crew 2 0:0
2022 3. Round Columbus Crew 2 - Toronto FC 2 4:2
2022 2. Round Columbus Crew 2 - Toronto FC 2 2:1

For games that were decided on penalties the score after 120 minutes will be included in the ranking