| Squad | Appearances | ||
| sorting |
| Goalkeeper | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tom Hay |
|
England | 1859 | ||
| John Lindsay |
|
Scotland | 1862 | ||
| Defender | ||||||
| Giles Marsh |
|
England | 01/04/1868 | ||
| Jack McLennan |
|
Scotland | 1867 | ||
| Edmund Morgan |
|
England | 07/03/1868 | ||
| Midfielder | ||||||
| Joe Barr |
|
Scotland | 1867 | ||
| Joe Clegg |
|
England | 01/05/1869 | ||
| George Haworth |
|
England | 17/10/1864 | ||
| William Shuttleworth |
|
England | 01/04/1868 | ||
| John Stevenson |
|
Scotland | 10/12/1861 | ||
| James Tattersall |
|
England | 03/06/1867 | ||
| Forward | ||||||
| Joseph Barlow |
|
England | 10/09/1870 | ||
| Walter Bowman |
|
Canada | 11/08/1870 | ||
| Arthur Elliott |
|
England | 1868 | ||
| William Faulds |
|
Scotland | 1867 | ||
| Pat Gallocher |
|
Scotland | 25/04/1865 | ||
| Joseph Irvine |
|
England | |||
| Johnny Kirkham |
|
England | 26/02/1868 | ||
| William McKay |
|
Scotland | |||
| John McVicker |
|
Northern Ireland | 29/04/1868 | ||
| Thomas Pendergast |
|
England | 12/01/1870 | ||
| Sam Thomson |
|
Scotland | 14/02/1862 | ||
| Jimmy Whitehead |
|
England | 1870 | ||
